Jerkbait Vs Crankbait: Understanding The Main Difference (Updated For 2023)

In the world of fishing, choosing the right bait can significantly impact your success. Among the myriad options available, jerkbait and crankbait stand as popular choices, each with their unique attributes and uses. We are going to understand the main difference between jerkbait vs crankbait.

Jerkbait, characterized by its lifelike design and erratic movement, mimics injured baitfish, enticing predatory fish to strike. It often features treble hooks and a slender profile, allowing for precise control and versatile presentation.

Jerkbait shines in colder water conditions when fish are less active. As its erratic action triggers the predator instinct, leading to aggressive strikes.

On the other hand, crankbait is renowned for its ability to dive into different depths and cover a large area efficiently. With a wider body and a lip that induces a wobbling motion, crankbaits imitate a wide range of prey, such as crawfish or shad.

This bait excels in warmer water conditions when fish are more active, as its consistent movement entices fish to bite.

Let’s understand jerkbait and crankbait more deeply so that you should know what to use when you go out for fishing.

What Is A Jerkbait?

What Is A Jerkbait?

A jerkbait is a type of fishing lure that’s designed to create a fast-paced, erratic action underwater, mimicking the movement of an injured or panicked baitfish.

This unpredictable motion is achieved through a combination of design elements and angler technique. In shape, jerkbaits are typically elongated and slender, resembling the physical appearance of common baitfish species.

Equipped with one or more treble hooks, jerkbaits are geared to effectively snag a predator fish that’s enticed into striking the jerk bait.

The real power of a jerkbait comes to life in the hands of an angler. Rather than a simple cast and retrieve, using a jerkbait involves a specific technique.

As the name implies, the rod tip is ‘jerked’ in a series of rhythmic motions, causing sharp changes in the lure’s direction and speed. This mimics the frantic, darting movements of a distressed fish, a signal to predatory species that an easy meal is in sight.

Typically, jerkbaits perform best in colder water conditions. As fish metabolism slows down in colder temperatures, fish become less active and selective about their food. The floating jerkbait itself’s erratic motion triggers their predatory instinct even in these sluggish conditions, leading to more aggressive strikes.

Jerkbaits are available in various models, from floating to sinking varieties, each designed to imitate different types of baitfish and appeal to various types of predatory fish.

They’re also available in a wide range of colors and patterns, allowing anglers to adapt to varying water clarity and light conditions.

From freshwater to saltwater, jerkbaits are a versatile lure option fit for many fishing scenarios. Knowing how and when to use them can significantly enhance an angler’s success on the water.

Check out these Jerkbaits For Bass Fishing

What Are The Categories Of Jerkbaits?

Jerkbaits can be broadly divided into three categories: floating jerkbaits, suspending jerkbaits, and sinking jerkbaits.

Floating Jerkbaits are designed to float on the water’s surface or just beneath it. They are ideal for fishing in shallow water or over submerged vegetation.

These baits can be jerked aggressively to create a splash, mimicking a panicking baitfish. Often used in warmer weather, floating jerkbaits can entice a variety of predatory species lurking near the surface.

Suspending Jerkbaits are engineered to hover in the water column at a specific depth, often decided by the anglers based on where they suspect the fish to be.

When paused during retrieval, these jerk baits will maintain their position in the water, a feature that can be hugely beneficial in colder waters when fish are lethargic. The tantalizing hang time of the suspending jerkbaits can provoke strikes from even the most reluctant predators.

Sinking Jerkbaits, as the name suggests, sink when cast. The rate of sink can vary from slow to fast, making these baits versatile for fishing at different depths.

Sinking jerkbaits become particularly effective in deeper waters where other baits might struggle to reach. The sinking jerkbait’s ability to reach lower depths makes it a popular choice for hunting bottom-dwelling species.

Each category of jerkbait has its unique features and is designed to appeal to different species of fish under diverse fishing conditions. Understanding the characteristics and applications of each jerkbait category can help anglers make an informed choice, thereby increasing their chances of landing a catch.

What are The Advantages and Disadvantages Of Jerkbaits?

Advantages and Disadvantages Of Jerkbaits

One of the main advantages of jerkbaits is their versatility. They can be used in various water conditions, from calm and clear to choppy and murky, and at any water depth. Their slender design and variety of colors enable them to effectively mimic a wide range of baitfish species, making them attractive to a diverse array of predatory fish.

The erratic, jerking movement that jerkbaits produce is a powerful trigger for predatory fish, enticing them into striking even when they’re not actively feeding. This feature especially comes into play during colder water conditions, where traditional baits might fail to elicit a response.

Additionally, the wide array of jerkbaits available – floating, suspending, and sinking – allows for flexibility in angling strategy.

Whether you’re fishing in shallow waters over submerged vegetation, targeting fish suspended at mid-depth, or going after deep-dwelling species, there’s a jerkbait suitable for the task. This adaptability makes jerkbaits a valuable addition to any angler’s tackle box.

Disadvantages Of Jerkbait

However, jerkbaits also have several disadvantages. One of the significant drawbacks of jerkbaits is that they require a specific retrieval technique to be effective.

The art of jerking the rod in a rhythmic motion to produce the desired erratic action can be challenging for newbie anglers to master. It requires practice and patience, which may be frustrating for some.

Furthermore, the multiple treble hooks that jerkbaits often feature can lead to a higher possibility of snags, particularly when fishing in areas with dense structure or heavy vegetation. Such snags not only disrupt the fishing experience but can also result in loss of the lure.

Lastly, while jerkbaits’ ability to attract a wide variety of predatory fish is generally a benefit, it can sometimes be a disadvantage.

In waters with a high population of smaller, non-target species, these aggressive feeders may repeatedly strike at the jerkbait – a situation that can lead to frustration if the angler is targeting larger fish.

In conclusion, while jerkbaits offer a range of advantages that can enhance an angler’s success on the water, they also come with certain drawbacks that need to be considered. Understanding these pros and cons can help anglers decide when and how to utilize jerkbaits effectively in their fishing endeavors.

What Is Crankbait?

Jerkbait Vs Crankbait

A crankbait is another type of fishing lure favored by anglers for its ability to dive underwater and mimic the swimming action of a baitfish.

It comes in a wide variety of shapes, sizes, and colors, each designed to attract different species of fish in various fishing conditions.

Crankbaits are characterized by a plastic or metal lip that causes them to dive beneath the water’s surface when retrieved.

The size and angle of this lip determine the swimming depth and action of the crankbait. Typically, a larger lip will cause the lure crank bait to dive deeper and exhibit a wider wobbling action. While a smaller lip results in a shallower swimming depth and tighter wiggle.

Similar to jerkbaits, crankbaits can be very effective at triggering a predator’s instinct to chase and strike. Making them an essential tool in the angler’s arsenal.

However, unlike jerkbaits, which require a specific retrieval technique to mimic an injured or fleeing fish. Crankbaits merely need to be cast and reeled in at a steady pace to perform their enticing action. This “cast-and-retrieve” simplicity makes crankbaits an easier option for beginners to master.

Crankbaits are also categorized based on their buoyancy: floating crankbaits, which float at rest and dive when retrieved; and sinking crankbaits, which sink when cast and dive deeper during the retrieve. This characteristic, coupled with their bountiful shapes and colors, allows anglers to target fish at various water depths and in different conditions.

Despite their benefits, crankbaits also have certain drawbacks. Their treble hooks can be more prone to snags, similar to jerkbaits, and they may not be as effective in colder water conditions where a more erratic action, like that of a jerkbait, might be required.

You can also read about Crankbaits For Bass Fishing

Categories Of Crankbaits

There are two primary categories of crankbaits: shallow-diving and deep-diving. Shallow diving crankbaits are designed to target fish in water depths less than ten feet, making them ideal for fishing near the shoreline or over submerged structures like weed beds and rocks.

They typically have smaller lips and a more subtle action that allows them to work well in shallow waters without getting snagged.

On the other hand, deep-diving crankbaits are intended to reach depths greater than ten feet, making them an excellent choice for targeting suspended fish or those dwelling at the bottom of deep waters.

These lures feature larger lips that cause them to dive deeper and exhibit a wider wobbling action that can trigger bites from more sluggish fish.

Some other popular types of crankbaits include lipless crankbaits, which lack a diving lip but can be retrieved at varying depths by changing the speed of retrieval, and squarebill crankbaits, designed to deflect off cover and elicit reaction strikes.

Advantages and Disadvantages Of Crankbaits

Advantages and Disadvantages Of Crankbaits

Crankbaits offer several advantages to anglers. First and foremost, their simple “cast and retrieve” operation makes them a user-friendly option, especially for beginners.

Unlike jerkbaits, which require a specific retrieval technique, crankbaits produce their enticing wobble with a straightforward retrieval. This makes them easier and more convenient to use.

Secondly, the variety of crankbaits available allows for great versatility. With different shapes, sizes, and colors on offer, anglers can select a crankbait that best matches the local prey species.

This mimicry of local prey can significantly increase the chances of attracting target fish species. Additionally, the availability of shallow-diving and deep-diving crankbaits means anglers can effectively target fish at varying depths, catering to different fishing environments and conditions.

Thirdly, crankbaits’ ability to deflect off structure without getting snagged is another significant advantage. This feature is particularly useful when fishing in areas with a lot of cover. Such as submerged logs or rocks, where fish often hide.

Disadvantages Of Crankbait:

However, crankbaits also have some disadvantages. One limitation is their inability to elicit a biting response from fish in colder water conditions. In such scenarios, the erratic action of a jerkbait might be more effective at triggering a predatory response.

Another disadvantage is the propensity for crankbaits to get snagged due to their treble hooks. While they can deflect off structure, there’s still a high risk of getting caught in heavy cover or vegetation. This risk can lead to a frustrating fishing experience and potential loss of the lure.

Lastly, crankbaits’ wobbling action might not be as appealing to some fish species as the erratic action of jerkbaits. This could potentially reduce their effectiveness in waters populated by fish species that prefer more erratic movements.

In conclusion, while crankbaits have a set of distinct advantages and disadvantages. Their effectiveness largely depends on the angler’s understanding of the fishing conditions and the targeted fish species. With proper knowledge and usage, crankbaits can be a highly effective tool in an angler’s arsenal.

Jerkbait vs Crankbait: Which One Should You Use?

Jerkbait Vs Crankbait

Choosing between a jerkbait and a crankbait can be akin to selecting the right tool for a job.

You see, the dance of jerkbait is altogether different from that of a crankbait. The jerkbait, true to its name, jerks, darts, and suspends, mimicking an injured fish, a tantalizing treat too good for any predator to pass up.

It’s a performance that calls for a touch of drama, a bit of finesse from the angler. The retrieval technique is strategic – reel, jerk, pause, repeat. It’s this erratic, unpredictable movement that can be incredibly effective. Particularly in colder waters where bass are a bit more lethargic and need the extra incentive to strike.

Crankbaits, on the other hand, are the ‘set it and forget it’ lure of the fishing world. They offer a ‘cast and retrieve’ simplicity that’s a godsend, especially for beginners. Their rhythmic, wobbling action, powered by a steady retrieval, can be irresistible to many fish species.

The whole crankbait fishing family is a diverse one, with many members suiting different roles. Shallow divers are the shoreline whisperers, while deep divers seek out the denizens of the depths. Lipless crankbaits and squarebills bring their unique talents to the table, offering variety and versatility.

But every coin has two sides, and crankbaits have their downsides. They can be a bit too soft for cold water conditions, lacking the razzle-dazzle of a jerkbait’s performance. Their treble hooks can get snagged, especially in areas rich in cover.

So, in this battle of jerkbait vs crankbait, who emerges victorious? The answer, my fellow anglers, depends on the skirmish. The conditions of the water, the mood of the fish, and the skill of the angler all play a part. Each lure has its strengths and weaknesses, but both have a place in the angler’s toolbox.

When To Use Jerkbaits vs Crankbaits

Jerkbait Vs Crankbait

Jerkbaits are best used when fishing in colder water conditions or when targeting fish species that prefer erratic, unpredictable movements. They can also be effective in clear water where the fish have a better view of their prey. And might require a more convincing imitation to strike.

On the other hand, crankbaits are ideal for warm water conditions. And can work well in murky or stained waters where visibility is limited. They are also great for covering large areas and searching for active feeding fish.

Ultimately, the decision between jerkbaits and crankbaits comes down to understanding the behavior and preferences of the target fish species, as well as adapting to the current conditions on the water. Experimenting with different lure types and techniques can lead to success on any given day. So be open to trying new approaches.

With enough practice and experience, you’ll be able to choose the right lure for any situation and optimize your chances of landing that trophy catch. So next time you’re out on the water, don’t just stick to what you know – mix it up and see how jerkbaits and crankbaits can help you to catch fish whichever you want.

Final Thoughts On Jerkbait Vs Crankbait:

There is no clear winner in the debate about  jerkbait vs crankbait. It all depends on the specific fishing conditions and the fish species being targeted. Both lures have their strengths and weaknesses, making them valuable tools for any angler’s toolbox.

Understanding how and when to use each lure can greatly improve your chances of success on the water. Don’t be afraid to experiment and switch things up until you find what works best for you! Happy fishing!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top